You are past the warranty. Plain and simple. They are under no obligation to give you ANYTHING. Have you noticed that you are getting no sympathy here? It's a bummer that your holster broke. Sorry to hear that. However, Seidio hasn't done anything wrong here. I've got one that I got when I first got my Curve and it's still working fine. Suck it up and buy another one or use something else. Trashing on Seidio for this is NOT warranted.