Having used this clip for a week I can easily say that my initial impressions continue to hold true. This is a quality piece of hardware.

I have not seen any indication that the phone is being held too tight. It enters and exits the clip with no problem. Once in place it feels secure with no movement. The top clip does not appear to be stretched or anything that would indicate the case is too large for the clip mechanism.

In a weeks worth of use the rubberized plastic and felt lining have not shown any signs of wear and the rotating clip continues to be strong.

The only negative that I have found to this clip is that the inside of the clip has a metal grommet that scratched the outside of my belt when I tried to slide the clip along my belt. If I make sure to open the clip a little when sliding this does not happen, and it does not happen with normal wear. It's a little thing but really the only negative I have seen thus far.

I'll provided another update in a few weeks