If you had your choice between the BB Pearl and a Moto Krazr k1. Which would you choose and why?

I wont be using the data plan on either phone.

Well the Pearl, along with all other BB's have a pretty decent PDA built in, that might be one of your deciding factors. But for the BB to really live up to what it's built for the data plan is key.

personally dont care for Moto phones or their GUI. Sizewise they are probably similar with the pearl being slightly smaller volume I suspect. If you dont use the data or PIM functions then you probably dont need a blackberry. That said I still would not get a Moto