Had a chance to play with the 8520 over the weekend. Just was wondering what everyone's thoughts are on the durability of the optical trackpad vs. the trackball. I just don't care for it. Seems like it could scratch very easily and seems cheap when it clicks. Almost like cellophane plastic. I know the ball can get dust (I always use canned air on it) but I am curious to see how well the trackpad will hold up.

I would say the trackpad will hold up alot better than a trackball in terms of durability.
the fact its not a constantly moving part, affected by dust, lint, moisture etc.

It also wont be discoloured, but the scratching might be a problem. just like any other part though.

Wirelessly posted (Its All About the U!)

Jury is out

i think the pad is going to be longer lasting. i think the ball is just very slightly more accurate when your trying to locate something or go to a specific icon... but overall i think the pad is the future!

i would think that the trackpad should be more reliable than the trackball. Saying that 8520 is atargeted at the mid market so not sure what RIM has compromised in therms of quality. Its a good review so far but yes the trackpad takes a little while getting used to .

Trackpad rocks!

Wirelessly posted (Curve 8520)

I can only echo what's been said. Trackpad feels a lot more durable than ball, tbh I'm still getting used to it but feel it'll be a quick transition! Note you can have the pad on "silent"

I like it, my next device will have one, my wife just got the 8520, been playing with it all day, feels solid.

I love it! Had a few issues with the trackball on both the Bold and my original Curve. It feels durable and actually works better than I expected. Might go so far as to say its my favorite blackberry I've owned thus far

Although early reports are favorable, and it's GOTTA be more durable, the idea of a new technology in a RIM device scares me. I bought a Tour on day 1 and had the trackball issue. Side to side was unresponsive but up and down worked perfectly. My Bold's trackball was flawless. If a slightly re-designed trackball was such a problem for RIM, an entirely new technology for them gives me the heebie-geebies.

Wirelessly posted (Tmo's cheapest BB customer)

I guess only time will tell. I got a chance to play with a friend's 8520 the other day and I'm growing to like the trackpad. I already use it regularly on my laptop, so I guess I'm used to it already.

One thing though, the trackpad will probably be less of an eyesore when it gets dirty unlike the white trackball haha.

the first 2 hours of using this new device, i thought it sucked seriously! however, after 2 hours i needed to change my mind, the trackpad is brilliant! and i think it will last a lot longer than the trackball (time will show). in our company a malfunctioning trackball is about 70% of the hardware probs with blackberries

I love the trackpad, sadly had a factory fault on mine and sent it back, the trackpad was not properly seated and would sink in when scrolling.

the trackpad is great, however it's just like a mouse on a computer. with the trackball, you have hmm... a bit mroe "control" over where you're pointing your arrow to... while the trackpad may stutter at some times... rarely though. but maybe that's just my stubby thumbs lol

the material used for the trackpad is pretty solid, it's not some cheap plastic that scratches up easily.

imo it's much more durable than any trackball.

I've had zero problems with it's durability OR accuracy... I think it's much more reliable than the trackball. There's an initial sense of 'freedom' lost I guess, but after an hour or two, I was using it like I had never been without one. BIG improvement over the ball.

Fingerprints/smudges give me headaches, but other than that, this phone is pretty great.