For those that use the polyurethane protectors, how do you cope with the sticky edges?
As for the plastic, I actually like the in-the-box protector that comes with the phone. Are the plastic ones similar?
I've tried InvisibleShield and Bodyguardz. I don't care for the wavy appearance of the screen with invisibleshield. Bodyguardz are very similar in terms of strength, application, etc. but without the wavy appearance. They tend not to be as precisely cut though, so sometimes they don't fit perfectly. I have them for a couple of Nokias that are less than perfect. That said, the ones for my Bold are very good.
I'm going to try the anti-glare from Boxwave though, as I'm really tired of having to clean the screen.