Yes it's the same one I reviewed.
The Pouch has no belt clip. The Leather Holster is the same thing as the pouch but has a belt clip (and it's the one I reviewed.)
It does have flap you just can't tell from the picture because it's only showing the back. We went through this when it first came on the Blackberry web site a few weeks ago. rcg from Smart Phone Depot confirmed the part number was the same as the Leather Holster they were selling on their web site. I even had ordered one from RIM because I though it was different and ended up cancelling the order.