Success! Darn mapi32.dll file! The versions didn't match and as soon as I uploaded the newer file and rebooted, it worked!
Thanks everyone! One last question... it seems like emails are a little slow in getting to my BB. Is there a setting I may be missing on the server? Messages seem to get to my desktop and then lag about a minute and a half before hitting my BB. When I was using a hosted BES, the email would hit desktop and BB about the same time. I know, what's a minute and a half but figure I'd check to see if there's something I'm missing.