Quote:
Originally Posted by atmfrank
Unfortunately this problem points an issue with competing bluetooth technologies. Without going into the details I just want to share with you my observations with 8100 and 8800 BB's work with 4 different BT stack providers: Microsoft (XP stack), Linksys (modified Widcomm), Widcomm 5.0.1 and Toshiba 5.1.
The only working and repeatable DUN connection for the 8100/8800 I ever got to work was an IBM R51 laptop with a Linksys BT100 USB and the native Linksys. The BB Desktop Manager (latest version) *never* registers a BT connection, regardless of laptop/BT USB used. OBEX still doesn't work even with the Linksys.
My frustration is very high in particular with Dell (D630/D620/D610 laptops) and built-in Toshiba BT module. Nothing works here, the Dell stack (4.2), the latest Toshiba stack (5.1) both will not work, worse yet, the module cannot be disabled so that I could use any USB dongle with Widcomm drivers.
Hours after hours spent with less than desirable results. My IT department supports about 50 BB users in the company (7100/8700/8100/8800). Travelers will continue to use USB cables for DUN.
I am giving up on BT and BB. I read somewhere that Vista drivers might fix things for good, but I have no patience left.
|
The scoop on the drivers is kind of a complicated story, but here's how I understand it, and this has been my experience as well:
- The Vista/XP Built-in Bluetooth stack only supports several profiles, like HID (Mouse and Keyboards, etc), Wireless Bypass (RIM Sync), and PAN Networking (Windows Internet Sharing). There is no support in the Vista/XP native stack for DUN thanks to Microsoft's total conversion of their mobile devices to PAN/ICS networking. (When will apple allow MacOS to run on PCs? - I can't wait!)
- RIM only supports the above Microsoft stack for sync (thanks RIM! Only about 25% of BT dongles run on this driver, so there's obviously no support for other non-MS supported devices when you want to sync with Desktop Manager.
- The other drivers, such as WIDCOMM or Broadcom, or BlueSoleil (most drivers are based on one of those three) work great with Dial-up Networking, but since RIM only supports the MS stack in Desktop Manager, none of them work with Syncing to Desktop Manager.
- The interesting thing is that some devices (including my IOGear dongle) work with both the MS and WIDCOMM (or other) drivers, so you have a choice to make - Do you want to Sync wirelessly, or tether.
I came to these conclusions after buying and trying both a WIDCOMM-based (IOGear) device, and a BlueSoleil (RadioShack) adapter, and both yielded the same exact experience. I subsequently returned the BlueSoleil device, as having two was a waste, and RadioShack took it back for a full refund (it was also the more expensive of the two...)
I ended up installing the WIDCOMM driver that came with my device, and using it to Tether, which is more annoying to do with a huge USB cable, which isn't as hard to manage for the occasional sync operation.
I guess it just depends on your preference and which operation is a priority. Hope all of this information helps!