I am coming from a 7290 with the open top holster. It was always secure but extremely easy to pull out of the holster. I have been looking for something similar and have been looking at the Seidos.
The only concern that I have is, "how easy is it to pull it out of the holster, does it take two hands or can I do it with one?". That is what I loved about my 7290 - I could be walking across the parking lot with briefcase in left hand and be able to pull the phone from my holster and answer it using only my right hand.
How does that work with the Seido holsters?
Thanks!